Tuesday, April 14, 2015

Why Them?

They say "Grass is always green on the other side". But what am going to talk about in this blog, the quote may or may not hold true.

Before I begin, want to say that all these are my thoughts alone. Am not putting in your mouth, so whether you desire to read further is completely on your choice and not mine. Also, I am responsible for what I say, not for what you understand.
Oh, and I am a little agitated too, so ignore the anger and foul words, if any.


Today's 14th April. Happy Ambedkar Jayanti to whoever wishes to accept it gracefully or with little confidence. Remaining ones, ignore. Yup, I belong to 'that' community, and today is our festival, san as is called in Marathi. Just like it's Diwali (if that makes you understand) for many of you. Ah yes, hence so many crackers around, if you are wondering what people are celebrating.

 So I was walking on the road this evening and overheard a conversation of a passerby. "Today and on 6th December, it's difficult to move around Dadar area. Half of Dadar is blocked because they come, everything is so dirty. Unnecessarily."
And then, "Dude! You shouldn't have spoken the last word." I said to myself. Wanted to talk to the passerby, but then I couldn't as had to tend to some work. Since then it's running in my head and now thought of putting these thoughts on this blog.

Do you too agree with what the passerby was talking about? Then I feel this post is for you to read, only if you are ready to understand with an empty cup, and not full of predefined concepts running in your head.

Don't judge too soon.

Do you celebrate Ganesh Chatturthi, Navratri, Eid, etc. either directly or indirectly? Ever questioned the same thing then? On 14th April and 6th December it's just a portion of Dadar that is cordoned off. That too for a day or two. What happens during Ganesh Chatturthi and Navratri to almost most part of the city or during Eid around Mohd Ali Road? The roads are pretty much empty, right?
Talking about cleanliness.
'They' dirty the road around. 
Ah but this dirt gets cleaned up the next morning. What about the dirt that happens in the sea when the idols are immersed during Ganesh Visarjan and Navratri, apart from the ones on the road? Who cleans the sea?

Errr, some thoughts started withering? Don't worry, I won't be telling anything new here. Will be just showing you what you have been ignoring all this while.

'They' get reservation.
I want to filter my audience at this stage. How many of you are female, and have made use of reservation in various fields for females at some or other point of life? For the males, how many of you have mother, sisters, aunt, female friends who made use of this 'reservation act for females' and you did not question them at all then?
I guess my target audience size has reduced considerably with so many hypocrites out.

I understand your opposition to the idea of reservation the government started, which is valid. But you need to understand the other side of the truth too, in such a scenario it is required. It is an act to uplift the downtrodden that they will at least get a chance, when all this while they did not. When they see the government is trying to boost it, few get confidence, a platform to showcase their talent, which in the earlier times was never allowed to come out.
I see around in my community. The condition has not improved much. Will take some time for it to happen. It took these couple of decades just for the idea to appear, imagine how long will it take to come in practice.

This reservation is creating more space instead of bridging. 
At this point the dialogue in the movie 'Sarkar' comes to my mind when the villains  were plotting how to kill Amitabh Bachhan's character and the swami speaks, "Sarkar ek soch hai. Hame us soch ko marna hai." The dialogue may not be exact word, but something similar.
The point being, the idea of barrier getting created should come from the source and not from the victim. Have an open mind, accept everyone equally and then you won't require the reservation in the first place. But this 'acceptance' itself is missing from a major part of the source. The source being people from so called 'upper caste'.
What? Did I hear you say it was in the past and not in the present age? Darling, it's high time you open your eyes. Even today the upper caste people look at Dalits as if they're doing a favour by talking or dealing with them. Have seen that a lot since years, have been seeing that. Oh, I have been on the receiving end too, so all I speak is from first hand experience. So if this has been happening in the metropolitan city like Mumbai, you can just imagine the situation in other part of the country, if have to go by the clichés.
Honestly tell me, how many of your parents have 'warned' you to fall in love with any community people, but not 'them'? Ask around you. In my experience, have come across 7 of 10 people who have been told this and even believe in themselves too. And I have been a victim of this belief, first hand.

Am not sure if you are ready to hear more examples.

Many of them are just there to take the advantage of reservation or many flout the law.
To answer this, I want to take an analogy. Do you drive or ride? How many times have you bribed the cops to get away? Or let me come to even simpler example in the analogy. How many of you most of the times stop your vehicle after you cross the stop line at a red signal? Are you aware of the fact that you need to stop your vehicle before the Stop Line and not after? How many of honk unnecessarily while on the road? How many of you jump a red signal?
Maybe you're not aware, but you're very much doing things that is against the law and 'are taking advantage of the law'?
I do not wish to speak anything further on this. The analogy speaks for the topic itself.

On a promotional mode, to read in detail about the analogy, do find it on this link horn-not-ok-please

So let's just start treating everyone equally, reduce the discrimination from the source and then see, there won't be a need of reservation at all.

All in good 'faith'.




The author of this post:
- Calls up police after 10 o'clock if they play music on loud speaker whether it is Ganesh Chatturthi, Navratri or Ambedkar Jayanti. Yes, he had complained the previous night.
- Stops behind the stop line, rarely honks and does not jump traffic signal. Whoever has been a co-passenger would want to disagree?
- Likes to live on logic many a times. And doesn't approve of an idea if it doesn't fit the logic.
- Has friends from various faith and doesn't discriminate them on the basis of caste.
-Is sometimes a hypocrite, himself. Afterall, he's human.

8 comments:

  1. Hi Author! Your blog post has served as a gentle reminder that we need to care more. That you are a good friend and I know your intentions are genuinely concerning is also beautifully kick-ass.

    Your post beautifully illustrates one of my favourite quotes: A bird doesn't sing because it has an answer, it sings because it has a song.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank You Dear Anonymous for your kind words. Just like as they say, Every drop makes an Ocean, these words of encouragement helps too.

      And if possible, do share it within your circle. Not just the blog, but if you can put in the idea even more gracefully and spread it across, that'll do too.
      Who knows if it might help someone, someday.

      Thank You once again. :)

      Delete
  2. Very good Supk. Our forefathers & we all have suffered alot by so called upper caste. This type of many more blog will help to narrow the gap between them & us. Keep it up.

    ReplyDelete
  3. A little push to the oppressed or the downtrodden can be given in terms of monetary benefits, the quota system is ruining our country. People who really want to do well, will use the government aids to the fullest in the right direction. Quota is NOT the correct and justifiable solution. I've read about prisoners in many nations taking advantage of the prison's education program to earn a college degree.
    What about people who have worked their backside off for a college seat, but aren't a part of any quota, and failed to make the cut due to infinitesimal percentage difference (due to the quota system)?
    I know many of these downtrodden people (my classmates in juniour college) who have taken undue advantage of this system. They barely studied the entire year (busy having fun) and got into medical/engineering. Isn't that a slap in the face for people who swotted for their dreams?

    ReplyDelete
  4. So, even though I requested them to post it on this blog, but the discussions and debates happened on Facebook. For those who directly landed up on the blog and want to know views of other people, let me copy and paste it over here for others to read. Hope, that's okay?


    Siddhesh Rane:
    Well done ! But bro I have a few critical points though on reservation:
    1. You want people to think and treat equally while being reserved for IITs,IIMs, IISc, and all the Government as well as Private Colleges in India.
    Disadvantage: You Promote Inequality among youth whose just started his college life and will not forget this for the rest of his life irrespective of his religion !
    2. Reservations if held should be for the economically poor rather than base it on a caste system which is obsolete now.
    Example: Imagine our Cricket team was to be selected based on Castes and Quotas, Sachin Tendulkar or Sunil Gavaskar would have never made it !! rest all points I agree with u !! Cheers !!

    Arnesh Ghose:
    To counter the second point above, the caste is not obsolete in India. The dalits, who are a lower-caste community, are still downtrodden and economically and socially oppressed. Hence, unfortunately, even today, the economically backward is also, too a large extent socially backward. And 'socially backward' would also include minority communities like certain sections of Musalmans. As for your first point - Like Supraket mentions, a little push, a little support, for those who would otherwise not be able to afford or be a part of such institutions is required. Rather than opposing that, why not do away with the 'management quota'? Why are we fine with that? People who pay for their seat in institutions and people who have theirs reserved for be sc/St/obc are on the same platform, now are they not? While the latter is claiming the reservation due to the lack of opportunity and social oppression, the former - due to the lack of adequate academic acumen.

    Siddhesh Rane:
    @Arnesh, I am against Quota System be it any type, and as far downtrodden are concerned, upliftment will only come from within not through Quota, if you must have noticed quotas only give u a certain percentage to be the part of the college but the fees of the college is the same ! So basically even by supporting the quota you are uplifting the rich Downtroddens !

    Siddhesh Rane:
    And a lota such doctors are Dalits who have benefited from the Quota and yet they aren't able to prescribe medicines properly !

    Sachin Khairnar:
    Dear @Siddhesh Rane have you heard of "DALIT" Doctors whose practice, social respect and (yes!) earnings have multiplied just because they changed their "Surname" (Last Name). It helps them from social discrimination based on caste. If discrimination starts with very name, would you support merit or society?

    Regarding quota in education: Worry not my friend the governments policies will make education expensive for a backward class to afford.

    विद्येविना मती गेली | मतीविना नीति गेली | नीतीविना गती गेली | गतीविना वित्त गेले |
    वित्ताविना शुद्र खचले | इतके अनर्थ एका अविद्येने केले! - Mahatma Phule

    (Lack of education leads to lack of wisdom, which leads to lack of morals, which leads to lack of progress, which leads to lack of money, which leads to the oppression of the lower classes. See what state of the society one lack of education can cause!)

    Regarding Merit: There are no traffic jam on the extra mile!!!


    Siddhesh Rane:
    @sachinkhairnar that extra mile costs many time ! And in today's world time is money !

    Sachin Khairnar:
    yep! In words of Albert Einstein "The difference between ordinary and extra ordinary is that little extra" smile emoticon

    ReplyDelete
  5. Whoa. This thing had gone down before I could respond. Thanks to someone who liked it, got my attention back again.

    Am not denying that a lot of people are misusing Reservations. But then, that's human nature isn't it?
    Take an example. You (and this you is a 3rd person perspective, and not specifically YOU) go out to dine out with friends. Do every single one of the friends present eat equally? Don't some eat less and some eat more? And amidst that, don't some try to hog in a little more by grabbing someone else's portion?
    Yes, happens?
    Now take this example and multi multiply to the country's population and that's what is happening. Whether you want it or not, human psychic is such that you can't get 100% full proof idea for it. Any Psychology students, out here?
    When burning a coal doesn't give 100% efficiency, we are humans with emotions!

    I just got done working at an event. At the Fashion Week. Photographers pit in front of the ramp. After the first day, everyone had "reserved" their seats. No one was ready to shift. I used to bounce from one place to the other. No doubt even I did use the " That's my place! " a few many times, but then I moved around as well.

    This was last week. Which year is it? 2015. Did anyone say it doesn't happen in today's date? Just because it's not on paper or in any rule, please don't turn a blind eye that it doesn't happen in reality.

    All am trying to say is, along with the misused ones, there have been a lot of benefits too. Why is everyone overlooking it?

    ReplyDelete
  6. And the comments further follows:

    Khaliq Parkar:
    what is this presumption that only "reserved" doctors prescribe bad medicine, reserved IITians can't study at par, reserved govt servants don't work. There are as many shitty brahmin doctors, kshatriya IITians and all sorts of castes and communities that make up the lazy petty bureaucrats.

    Also this generic "Quota spoils our country" "Quota is wrong" are without any basic supportive argument or data.

    "Barely studied the entire year" is not a reserved seat thing - sorry, but it is Every fucking undergraduate student behaviour. It is what the catholic girl in St. Xavier's does, it is what the Tam Brahm in Wilson does, it is what a Muslim from Dongri does.

    To suggest that "reserved quotas" as a generic bloc don't study is the real slap in the face of extremely hard working students from scheduled caste and scheduled tribes and visually impaired and physically impaired and learning disabled and economically disadvantaged who have been struggling against judgmental priviledged brats who think they know what happens outside their private bedroom walls because they saw "reality" on YouTube or something.

    ReplyDelete

Thank You for your valuable input!
Appreciate it, really! :)